 |
Weather check: mostly clear skies, excellent visibility
with just a few surprising overcast & misty days. |
Western Breach - KINAPA says ‘We are modifying our position’.
Since the deaths of 3 climbers on January 4th of this year the Western Breach assault route to the summit
of Kilimanjaro has been closed from 4871m to 5726m pending an investigation into the causes of the
accident. In the week directly following the accident DAT’s Mountain Team Leader led a team to determine
the cause and proposed to the head of Tanzania National Parks, Gerald Bigurube, that the claimed cause
given in the early reports was erroneous, that the accident resulted from subsidence of a residual glacial
deposit directly above the existing route and that therefore a modification to the route was needed in order
to be able to safely reopen the route. In June, following five successive reconnaissance expeditions this route
was finally agreed and KINAPA reported that they expected to have the new route opened by the end of July.
Later in July however, Willy Shukuku, ex-NOLS, of Janam Wilderness Explorers in Kenya, who has been
contracted to oversee the Breach re-opening operation visited the area again and subsequently gave his
verdict to TANAPA that despite his earlier recommendations for the route’s imminent re-opening he now
judges the proposed new route to be impassable for potentially inexperienced trekkers in the dry season
because of the presence of dry ice. There is no vetting of applicants wishing to climb the route.
|
|
 |
In a discussion on 12th August Dr James Wakibara, Chief Ecologist
of Kilimanjaro National Park (KINAPA) told our Mountain
Team Leader that KINAPA had therefore decided to modify their
position on re-opening the route. When asked for their current
stance he replied that they were now deliberating two alternatives:
either to close the route altogether or else to allow the route to be
used at certain times of year only.
TANAPA’s position is in contrast to management practice of
wilderness areas elsewhere in the world where climbers understand
that the onus of personal risk management lies with the
climber himself or herself and that the duty of the authorities
responsible for the area extends no further than alerting prospective
visitors to the peculiar nature of objective risks associated with
any particular area of the mountain being visited. |
Willy Shikuku, 2nd from left, working on the
Western Breach in June 2006 with Climbing
Mountain Team Leader and assistants.
|
|
 |
Father and son on course for record.
A father and son from Canada who are
aiming to climb the seven summits in less
time than anyone has previously
achieved, summitted Kilimanjaro, their
third of the Seven Summits with us this
month.
If the team is able to summit Mount Everest
by May 5th 2007 they will set a new
world record of 294 days for the ascent of
the highest mountain on each of the
seven continents.
Two of the team of three were already
acclimatised from an ascent of Mount
Elbrus, 5642m, just two weeks before
and appeared to reach the summit effortlessly,
modifying their schedule en route
in order to return all the way to the Mweka
exit gate the very same day!
|
 |
|
Kilimanjaro suffers three unrelated deaths in one week.
Care when booking your ascent and planning personal aspects of preparation and kit choice is always advised
and it is a sore regret of ours how lightly many of the fellow climbers we encounter on the mountain
have approached their own challenge.
This week we were saddened to learn of three people who were killed while making their way to the summit
with three different tour operators. The official version of these deaths is yet to be released however our own
guides report the cause of one of these deaths as apparently being related to hypothermia. The body of a
French lady who died during her night assault was collected by KINAPA’s rangers and returned to Barafu.
The rangers there complained that she was not adequately dressed for the summit. The mountain is a
potentially hostile environment and there is no safe substitute for an attentive and intelligent guide who has
been trained thoroughly to monitor those in his charge.
Last year saw 997 evacuations from the mountain however the number of deaths on Kilimanjaro is not known
but is estimated to be some 20-30 each year. Aside from hypothermia a large proportion of these deaths will
occur when a climber spends the night in Crater Camp at 5729m without first visiting the summit 166m higher.
Climbing higher during the day than where you will sleep is essential at critical altitudes as the climber’s
respiratory rate drops significantly during sleep, sometimes causing hypoxia if the climber hasn’t compensated
for this air intake reduction by taking the body to a height where the lower barometric pressure will
inform the body to adapt to lower oxygen levels. All guides can recite the mantra ‘climb-high-sleep-low’ and
yet this essential practice is wholesale neglected by nearly all climb co-ordinators at the altitude where it is
most critical.
|
Our new dual layer jackets arrive.
A new design of high altitude jacket has arrived and has already been field
tested. The climber, a commercial airline pilot, was asked to critically assess
the summit jacket and give constructive feedback for how to improve the
prototype. Despite being experienced in outdoor pursuits he claimed to be
completely at a loss as to how the design might be improved. He claims the
jacket offers ‘instant warmth’ and despite its bulk packs down easily into its own
compression sack. The jacket is synthetic and more resilient than the down
jackets it replaces. It has been designed in a collaboration between our Mountain
Team Leader and his Nepali equipment provider for his Himalayan climbs
and complements our range of breathable Gore-tex waterproofs and high
altitude down mitts. A limited number are already available for hire.
|
|
Unnecessary delays and medical emergencies on the Umbwe Route.
A perplexing aspect of current organisational procedure on the mountain is that all climbers and their support
teams are required to purchase their climbing permits from the nearest park gate to that from which they wish
to begin their climb. This means that in the peak season it is not unusual to be delayed until 1pm before being
able to start a climb despite arriving at the gate two hours beforehand. The gates lack modern methods for
verifying dollar notes and KINAPA staff are required to write down the serial numbers of every highdenomination
note that is tendered. Further, while it is TANAPA policy to tarmac roads to all National Park in very poor
condition.
During the first week in August one of our climbing teams was delayed for two hours while an automatic
transmission bus extricated itself from a culvert at the edge of the approach road to the Machame Gate. Our
guides report that some 30 other vehicles were similarly delayed. The team was required to purchase a
permit at the Machame Gate before backtracking 10km and driving onwards to the Umbwe Gate to
commence their climb. As a consequence of these delays the team only began their ascent at 3:15pm,
reaching their first camp by torchlight at 9:45pm. On the way they passed another group who was rushing in
their anxiety to reach camp before nightfall. One of their party had already succumbed to dehydration.
Fortuitously, one of our climbers was a doctor who was able to assist in ameliorating the casualty’s condition
and he was able to continue with his climb.
The episode highlights the urgent need for the authorities to capitulate to pressure to modernise their
registration system. All that would be required to end the problem of queuing and delays would be for the
National Parks to open a small kiosk at their headquarters in Arusha from which operators could purchase
permits the day before an ascent
|